Indulgently Fudgy 3 Ingredient Banana Brownies – Easy, Fudgy & Healthy
Have you ever stood in your kitchen at 11pm with overripe bananas threatening imminent counter-death and thought—what if…? That was me last Thursday, wearing mismatched socks and desperately craving something chocolate but refusing to haulsleigh myself to the grocery store. Three ingredients. That’s all it took to accidentally create what I now unashamedly call my midnight banana salvation squares. They’re technically brownies, but with a squishiness factor that makes traditional recipes look uptight. I’ve been kitchen-experimenting since my disasterous college days (more on that spectacular peanut butter explosion later), but these 3 Ingredient Banana Brownies – Easy, Fudgy & Healthy little marvels have become my go-to when the sweet tooth attacks but my motivation resembles that of a sloth on vacation.
My Twisted Brownie Awakening
So lemme tell you how these 3 Ingredient Banana Brownies stumbled into existence. Back in 2019—wait, was it 2018? Possibly 2020 during the Great Flour Shortage—anyway, sometime in that general era, I was staying at Caroline’s lake house where the nearest store was 42 minutes away (I timed it after a traumatizing hot sauce emergency). The bananas had reached that leopard-spot stage of ripeness where they practically melt when you look at them sideways.
I’ve always had what my grandmother called “kitchen intuition,” which is a polite way of saying I refuse to follow recipes properly. This tendency has resulted in some spectacular failures (the Thanksgiving gravy incident of 2016 still comes up at family gatherings), but occasionally—very occasionally—it leads to accidental brilliance.
These brownies went through seven iterations before reaching their current glory. First they were too gloopy (technical term), then too banana-forward (another technical term I just made up), then finally achieved what I call the “swump-factor”—that perfect balance between fudgy density and cloud-like tenderness. Sometimes I make them in Connecticut, where my oven runs hot, and sometimes in my boyfriend’s ancient apartment where the temperature gauge is purely decorative. They turn out differently every time, which is part of their charm!
(I’ve thrown perfectly good batches away because they weren’t “swumpy” enough. I’m not proud of this.)
What You’ll Need (The Bare-Bones Version)
- 3 EXTREMELY ripe bananas (I’m talking brown-black skins that make your roommate say “shouldn’t those be in the trash?”) – mushed into submission
- 1⅓ cups almond butter (Or your favorite nut butter… I’ve used peanut butter in desperation scenarios but it makes them taste like, well, peanut butter. Sometimes I use half-chunky almond butter for texture excitement)
- ¼ cup + 1 semi-heaping tbsp unsweetened cocoa powder (The Dutch-processed kind gives a deeper color, but regular works fine if you’re not trying to impress judgy in-laws)
- OPTIONAL BUT STRONGLY ENCOURAGED: ½ tsp vanilla extract (The real stuff. I will die on this hill)
- A pinch of salt (Literally whatever your fingers grab. I never measure this. Sometimes it’s too much. We learn and grow)
- IF YOU’RE FEELING FANCY: ⅓ cup chocolate chips to fold in (This technically makes it 4 ingredients, I know—call the recipe police)
What I love most about these 3 Ingredient Banana Brownies is their forgiving nature. Precise measurements? We don’t know her.
The Baking Chronicles: Instructions-ish
- Preheat your oven to 350°F. Or 355°F if you’re feeling rebellious. My aunt Dina claims 345°F makes them “more sophisticated” but she also puts ketchup on pasta, so…
- Grab your squishiest bowl—I mean, a mixing bowl—and perform what I call the “banana obliteration.” This involves smashing those overripe bananas with whatever instrument brings you joy. Fork, potato masher, the back of a measuring cup… I’ve even used a clean shampoo bottle in dire circumstances. Get them to applesauce consistency with maybe a few distinguished lumps for character.
- Now for the critical part. Add your almond butter and combine using the Mitchell fold (named after my imaginary cooking mentor who insists that stirring should always follow the lunar cycle). Just kidding – mix it however you want until it looks like something between cake batter and tar.
Add your favorite brownie recipe from our site here for more chocolate inspiration!
- Introduce the cocoa powder gradually while mixing. I once added it all at once and created what can only be described as a cocoa dust storm in my kitchen. Found powder in my ears the next day. Not recommended unless you enjoy looking like you’ve been mining for chocolate.
- At this point, pause and assess the consistency. It should ribbon off your spatula in a way that makes you think “is this too runny?” followed immediately by “nah, it’ll be fine.” This is the sweet spot. If it’s too thick, add another smidge of banana. Too thin? Extra cocoa powder, but carefully—this isn’t a science, it’s more like kitchen jazz.
Mix in vanilla + salt if using. The chocolate chips get gently folded in last with what I call a “respectful swirl”—meaning don’t overdo it or they’ll all sink to the bottom and create a chocolate layer that, while delicious, isn’t what we’re going for in these 3 Ingredient Banana Brownies – Easy, Fudgy & Healthy.
Dump—er, elegantly transfer—the mixture into a parchment-lined 8×8 pan. Or whatever pan you have clean. I’ve used a round cake pan in emergencies and just called them “brownie circles.”
5.5) Smooth the top with your spatula. Or don’t. Texture is rustic and charming or whatever.
- Bake for 25 minutes—actually, make that 22-28 minutes, depending on how your oven feels that day. They’re done when the edges look set but the center still looks slightly underbaked. Trust me on this. If you wait until a toothpick comes out clean, they’ll be too dry and you’ll have banana bread instead of 3 Ingredient Banana Brownies.
- THE HARDEST PART: Let them cool completely. I mean it. I’ve ruined countless batches by cutting in too soon. They need time to firm up, like a good relationship or gelatin.
Random But Essential Tips
• These brownies actually taste BETTER the next day. Something magical happens overnight in the fridge—the banana flavor mellows and the fudginess intensifies. I call this the “brownie metamorphosis” (another term I invented that sounds scientific but isn’t).
• DON’T store these on the counter for more than a day unless you enjoy science experiments. Refrigerate them for up to a week, though they’ve never lasted that long in my house.
• If your bananas aren’t ripe enough, you can force-ripen them in the oven (my shocking hack that nobody knows about except everyone).
• Sometimes I add a sprinkle of cinnamon—controversial, I know. My boyfriend claims this ruins them, but he also thinks cilantro tastes like soap, so his opinion is compromised.
• The center pieces are superior to edge pieces. This is not up for debate.
Kitchen Gadgets That Changed My Brownie Game
SILICONE SPATIAL-SHOVEL ★★★★★
The one with the slightly curved edge that gets under everything perfectly. Life-changing for removing these sticky brownies.
I dropped mine in the garbage disposal once and still used it after. Don’t judge me.
Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07DKZV92J
GRANDMA RUBY’S ANCIENT MIXING BOWL ★★★★★
It’s ceramic, chipped, and holds exactly the right amount of batter. I’ve measured.
Scientists claim modern bowls work the same but they’re wrong. This one has seasoning.
Amazon: Not available because it’s from 1962 and possibly contains lead
But What If I Want To Complicate Things?
For the “I can’t leave well enough alone” crowd (I see you, I am you), here are some variations:
• Swirl in 2 tablespoons of peanut butter on top before baking for what I call “fudgy banana confusion squares”—looks weird, tastes amazing.
• Add orange zest. A bizarre choice that works mysteriously well with the banana and chocolate. My friend Taylor says it tastes “continental,” whatever that means.
• Pumpkin puree can substitute for one banana if you’re feeling autumnal or dealing with a banana shortage. The texture gets more dense, but in a good way, like memory foam for your mouth.
I once tried adding protein powder to make these “healthy healthy” instead of just “kinda healthy” and created something with the texture of wet sand. Some experiments don’t need repeating.
The One Question Everyone Asks
“Can I use a different nut butter?”
Yes, but with consequences. Cashew butter makes these 3 Ingredient Banana Brownies – Easy, Fudgy & Healthy almost too creamy (if that’s possible). Peanut butter creates what I call “Elvis brownies” because they taste like his famous sandwich. Sunflower seed butter works if you’re dealing with nut allergies but turns them slightly green after a day due to some chemical reaction that looks alarming but is harmless according to the Randall Principle of Seed Reactivity (which I just made up but sounds legitimate).
Final Brownie Thoughts
These 3 Ingredient Banana Brownies – Easy, Fudgy & Healthy have saved countless overripe bananas from the compost bin and my sanity on multiple occasions. They’re the dessert equivalent of those versatile black pants that work for both funerals and dinner parties—adaptable, reliable, secretly comfortable.
Will they replace traditional brownies? For some occasions, absolutely. For others, maybe not. Can you add more ingredients to make them fancier? Of course, but then they wouldn’t be 3 Ingredient Banana Brownies anymore, would they?
I’m currently working on a 2-ingredient version, but science may not be ready for such simplicity. Until then, enjoy these with an inappropriate amount of vanilla ice cream, preferably eaten directly from the pan while standing in front of an open refrigerator at midnight.
What’s your favorite brownie texture? Too personal? Sorry.
Bake with reckless abandon,
Chef Maddie (Self-appointed Brownie Alchemist, Third Place Winner of my neighborhood’s “Most Creative Use of Fruit” contest, 2022*)
*The contest may have only had three entries. Details unimportant.
Related Recipes
